colringbk
|
| Subject: Posted: May 27, 2008 08:21 am |
|
|
Pretty good. I really like how thematic your deck was, except for the Death Star Hangar. I didn't see that fitting in too well, but you had to use it strategically.
Its too bad that this fleet/deck had to be limited to 30 stars. Seriously, the Battle of Endor was much, much bigger than that! I would have petitioned to have it twice as big, or at least 45 stars. Of course, that leaves a longer night and you did play 4 games it seems.
Why did you have the A-Wings in reserve? They seem pretty strong on the Attack and could have been forerunners in the fight. Also, did the fleet have to be Base Set only? It would have been helpful to use some Ground Assault Space Units in there, like some B-Wings.
Consider this: Switch out Masanya for Redemption. Now you've got one extra defense point, but you did lose the Turbolaser icon. But you picked up the Droid icon, too, which would be helpful with all of those Droid icons in your deck. So, use Gray Squadron B-Wing to bring in that Turbolaser. You do lose a little damage, and you'll have to cut two stars from something to fit it in.
BTW, what were the other choices for your factions and themes based on the game? It would stink to pick Ground Units Rebel side for Battle of Endor. What is that? A couple of speeder bikes and Chewbacca's AT-ST? Against other AT-ST, many speeder bikes, and an AT-AT in there?
|
|
boms
|
| Subject: Posted: May 27, 2008 12:54 pm |
|
|
Hi.
Thanks for the input! I found Death Star Hangar to be thematic, after all, how else does Luke get in?
We've tried more stars before, and it takes too long. We played 4 rounds, and had to include a finale for the two with most points, and was done in three hours ++, beginning play at 4.30 pm and was done by closing time 8.00 pm (on thursdays).
On the two rounds I lost I had the A-wings up-front, but I enjoy playing X-wings more. They've always been "closest to my heart" of all the original ships. The B-wings I dropped because of their 3* (the uncommons at least) and the 2* because I felt the A-wings were a better choice.
I am the envoy, but this tournament was suggested by one of my players. The theme was to choose side, rebel or empire and then location, space or Edor, all sets allowed. If one would choose rebel planetside, I'd allow some "captured" empire-stuff, but one would still have to have the correct cards! I have one (usually three) of every card and ship, pretty much, and feel that I have to big an advantage over my players when I build my fleets, and as such I am usually very strict, with myself, in being thematic when builing theme-decks. (Unlike one of my players who brought 3xMustafar Mining Platform, and Dagobah Swamp
My main problem with this deck is the lack of proper objectives. It's not too hard to destroy combat cards as objectives, with a defense of 7-9*..
-Robert-
| quote from colringbk: |
Pretty good. I really like how thematic your deck was, except for the Death Star Hangar.
Its too bad that this fleet/deck had to be limited to 30 stars. Seriously, the Battle of Endor was much, much bigger than that! I would have petitioned to have it twice as big, or at least 45 stars. Of course, that leaves a longer night and you did play 4 games it seems.
Why did you have the A-Wings in reserve? They seem pretty strong on the Attack and could have been forerunners in the fight. Also, did the fleet have to be Base Set only? It would have been helpful to use some Ground Assault Space Units in there, like some B-Wings.
Consider this: Switch out Masanya for Redemption. Now you've got one extra defense point, but you did lose the Turbolaser icon. But you picked up the Droid icon, too, which would be helpful with all of those Droid icons in your deck. So, use Gray Squadron B-Wing to bring in that Turbolaser. You do lose a little damage, and you'll have to cut two stars from something to fit it in.
BTW, what were the other choices for your factions and themes based on the game? It would stink to pick Ground Units Rebel side for Battle of Endor. What is that? A couple of speeder bikes and Chewbacca's AT-ST? Against other AT-ST, many speeder bikes, and an AT-AT in there?
|
|
|
colringbk
|
| Subject: Posted: May 27, 2008 04:37 pm |
|
|
| quote from boms: |
Thanks for the input! I found Death Star Hangar to be thematic, after all, how else does Luke get in?
|
Yeah, I thought about that too. I guess you could stretch it like that.
|
|