main page of Miniature TradingMiniature Trading

We find for you the miniatures you need

Miniature Reviews: games > Pirates CSG  
miniature review Orca: Beached whale anyone?
Miniature Review
Orca: click to enlarge
Orca

Miniature text:
When this ship carries no cargo, she gets +S to her base move.
  • Collector's Number: 040
  • Faction Affiliation: Pirate
  • Rarity: C
  • Type: Ship
  • Point Value: 6
  • Cargo Space: 1
  • Base Move: S+S
  • Cannons: 5S-4S
Orca
Beached whale anyone?

written by vosarnath Premium Member 

General description:
The Orca is famed as being “one of the fastest ships ever to sail”. According to the flavour text her crew achieve this notoriety by working hard to keep her looking like a merchant ship. Not sure how these two are linked, but what a good job they do. She certainly looks deliciously fetching in her resplendent black and white stripey uniform.

A pretty little two-masted ship that will look the part docked at your home island when the starting whistle is blown.

Uses:
With that famed speed, we must be looking at base S+S+S speed, right? Well, kinda. Her speed is S+S, but check out that ability “When this ship carries no cargo, she gets +S to her base move”, so as long as you’re not carrying anything, sure enough she’s got all the moves.

So what are you going to do with them? Dash to the nearest wild island and fill up with treasure, right? Wrong. Count the one cargo space. One. That’s one piece of treasure and she’s limping home at S+S.

She’s not a goldrunner then. So she must be a gunship? Wrong again. Cannons are 5S and 4S, so even if you decide to sacrifice an S move each turn to have a Captain on board and then get up close and personal with your opponent, you’re looking at a 39% chance each turn of a single hit, or a roughly 6% chance of both cannons hitting. Add a Musketeer for a 56% chance of a least one hit, but you lose the move and shoot.

Strategies and game play:
Well given her next to useless cannons, and her S+S speed when carrying crew, we need to look at what she can do on her own. An escort ship perhaps, blocking line of sight and taking a bullet for an otherwise vulnerable high-cargo goldrunner? She could wait near your home island and distract gunships long enough for your goldrunner to get home. If you’re really clutching at straws she could act as a cheerleader for those ships which get +1 for friendly ships within S. The possibilities are far from endless.

She becomes much more useful in a sealed deck tournament, where yer get what yer given. At 6 points you’re still not getting much bang for your buck, but a ship which can move S+S+S without a helmsman in those situations is quite valuable. She could explore wild islands for you, although of course that will take a turn without an explorer, but at that speed hopefully she’ll have beaten the opponent there. And if there’s a really choice piece of treasure there she could snap it up. A super-explorer would be nice, but the Pirates don’t have one.

Alternatively she could chase and harass your opponents’ goldrunners. She won’t do brilliantly in a scrap, but if a gold-laden enemy ship can be slowed down it could be worth the risk.

Combos with other miniatures:
Well with that one cargo space there’s not much room to get the best from crew. If you added a Helmsman you’d get, erm, S+S+S, so don’t do that. Her cannons aren’t good enough to justify losing an S segment for a Captain or Cannoneer crew. An Explorer would slow her down too much to justify his bearth. So, no combos.

Ways to counteract it:
Wait until it comes alongside and sink it. Shouldn’t be too difficult. Alternatively just ignore it and hope it goes away.

Strengths/Pros:
Cheap and fast in a sealed tournament situation.

Weaknesses/Cons:
Poor cannons. One cargo space. Inefficient when carrying crew.

Artwork and aesthetics:
Very pretty black and white sails. Looks the part. Nice ship to use if you’re doing a demonstration of the game.

Overall rating:
This ship wouldn’t see action in a constructed fleet, unless it was a very big one. If you had nothing else it could have some use in a sealed tournament. So it gets a 2.

 


Rating
You can rate this Miniature Review: was it useful for you? is it informative, and complete?

 



Discussion about this Miniature Review
Add your comments
Author Message
vosarnath 



Subject: Review. Akk.   Posted: February 17, 2008 07:41 pm Reply with quote  Report content icon

I wrote this review for the ship I love to hate, before I realised that there were actually 13 pages of reviews in addition to the one that I could see. It turns out that mercenary30 had reviewed it over a year ago. Still having written the review I decided to post.
Back to top  
colringbk 



Subject:    Posted: February 17, 2008 10:27 pm Reply with quote  Report content icon

I loathe the Orca. From the DJC set, it was the ship I got every other pack, and it was the ship that no one would trade for since they got one every other pack.

However, I do like her artwork. Nice review. Its neat to read reviews that point out the worthlessness of a ship. 4/5. I would have given you a five if you wrote:

"DON'T USE THIS SHIP. FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, DON'T USE THIS SHIP!"
Back to top  
phymatine 



Subject:    Posted: February 18, 2008 12:17 am Reply with quote  Report content icon

Glad you posted it! Orca is one of my favorite bad ships. My very favorite way to use it would be to lose it to a shark..."Your gonna need a bigger boat." It comes up both in my fleet and in my opponent's fleet surprisingly often. I have used it successfully before in a game, once. It was the support ship for the Selkie and would ram enemy ships to pin them (old pinning rules) so the Selkie's modified double-range guns could plink away at them. It eventually was sunk by a fort blocking cannonfire which otherwise would have hit the Selkie.
Back to top  
vladsimpaler 



Subject:    Posted: February 18, 2008 12:37 am Reply with quote  Report content icon

This ship is easily one of the bigger stains on the underpants of the Pirates faction.
Okay, that was a little weird, but you get my point.
It's a bad ship, although I feel the 2/10 is a little too nice for this ship.
Back to top  
Add your comments
Page 1 of 1  
Subscribe to this discussion
Search:  





search for a miniature | miniatures you have | miniatures you want | look for trades
your messages | references | miniature reviews | forums
affiliates | links | help